Thursday, December 6, 2012

Bigots under the skin

Today is the twentieth anniversary of the demolition of Babri Masjid in Ayodhya. By chance, tomorrow I am to visit  Ayutthaya, in Thailand, which is in fact named after the Indian original. There's enough to do on vacation that I normally wouldn't bother to blog. However this fateful day still resonates in my mind after twenty years. Not because I was personally impacted, or anyone I know was personally impacted. But because this is when I saw the appallingly foolish and self-destructive fascist agenda unfurl before my eyes for the first time.

As of that date it suddenly became fashionable, even in a place like TIFR, to whisper (or hint) unpleasant things about Muslims. This is particularly strange because on December 6, 1992 Muslims did nothing at all, except stare in horror at the TV set, as I did along with close friends, while a militant Hindu mob climbed all over the mosque and brought it down even as the police watched and did nothing. This was in pursuance of an agenda promoted by BJP leader L.K. Advani and his followers, according to which Lord Rama was born on the precise spot where the mosque stood, and building a Ram temple on the site (after demolishing the mosque) would somehow make India a great land again.

While withdrawing cash at the TIFR bank one suddenly started hearing strange comments exchanged between bank staff. The same was true in the canteen and I would struggle to find a place to sit where I would not be nauseated by some insinuation about Muslims. The apathetic-progressive atmosphere of academia was not immune to this infection. The day after the demolition a faculty colleague could not suppress his delight and assured me "the structure will never be rebuilt". He was right, as it turned out.

But the single most memorable comment came from a very well-known person at TIFR whom I will not name. While we were collecting used clothes and money to take to the refugees whose homes in Bombay had been plundered and who were cowering in shelters, this person stopped me in the colonnade at the point where Brahmagupta meets Bhaskara (for those who know TIFR). "I think religion is a personal matter" he started. "We should try to keep our views to ourselves". By then I had seen enough to know that this innocent-sounding statement was a prelude to something, and I was right. "Just one thing I've noticed" this gentleman continued. "Whenever there are riots, it's always Hindu women who are raped by Muslim men, never the other way around". I did not have the stomach to confront him with facts or even to continue the discussion. But today reading Bachi Karkaria's blog entry on the occasion, I was struck by her line "People I had known closely turned out to be unmitigated bigots just under their sophisticated skin". It's been exactly the same for me.

These "sophisticated bigots" did not personally bring down the mosque, nor would they ever engage in manifest politics. Their opinions surface only when they feel the atmosphere will tolerate it. Today the agenda of building a Ram temple at Ayodhya, and thereby miraculously converting India into a great country, is in shambles. This agenda has done terrible things to our social fabric but not one good thing for the nation's structure, morality or self-esteem, forget social or economic development (how could it possibly??). So at this time the bigots are hiding their views. But I don't intend to ever forget who they are, or what damage they did by conferring legitimacy on such an aberrant movement in India's history.


shaila mallik said...

So true, Sunil - it saddens me even more to think about it while reading your piece. I think that event changed post-independence India like 9/11 changed the world - forever.

admin said...

The problem always is this-- Statements like: "I didn't want to confront this man with data" are never actually supported with data. As a man whose parents were butchered by Muslims in front of his eyes, I cannot agree ever with pseudo secularists such as you Sunil. You have no real idea what you are talking about.

Sunil Mukhi said...

@admin: Too cowardly to reveal your real identity, Mr Admin? No problem. At least, you have a blog where you reveal your real opinions? And where you demonstrate that followers of one religion are statistically more likely to rape - or butcher - than followers of another religion? No, not even that? Somehow I thought not.

Anant said...

Good post. Thanks.

AK said...

I have always wondered how things like Holocaust happened, the perpetrators were not aliens who arrived from a far off planet, there were just humans like all of us. But now it is all clear (after reading your post); all you need is someone to create an atmosphere where the 'sophisticated bigots' feel free to express and enforce their opinions and voila, you can create any of the historical atrocities or create even brand new ones. Now that is a scary thought :-|

shafaq insaan said...

if you are back in mumbai here is a small effort at also keeping the public memory of that senseless violence alive so that it does not happen again.